Overview
Shut-off valves (angle stops) under sinks and toilets fail in two ways: they leak from the stem, or they seize completely and cannot be turned. Replacing one with a quarter-turn ball valve ($8–$15) is a 30–60 minute job. Two connection types exist: compression (clamps onto copper pipe with a ferrule) and push-to-connect (push-fit, for DIYers). Always shut off the main water supply before starting—this valve is the last defense before a flood.
Tips
Tip 1: Push-to-connect (SharkBite or similar) shut-off valves cost about $15 and remove the hardest part of the job—seating the ferrule. They are ideal for DIYers and have a lower failure rate for beginners.
Tip 2: Always replace a multi-turn shut-off valve with a quarter-turn ball valve. Multi-turn valves use a rubber washer that crumbles with age; ball valves rely on a stainless steel ball that never degrades.
Tip 3: Compression fittings seal metal-to-metal and do not need Teflon tape on the compression threads (only on the supply-line outlet threads). Tape on compression threads can prevent the nut from turning far enough.
Tip 4: If the copper pipe stub is too short (less than 1 inch protruding), you cannot get a compression or push-fit valve to seal. You will need to extend the stub with a coupling and a fresh piece of pipe, which requires soldering.
Tip 5: After installing, cycle the new valve on and off 3–4 times. New ball valves can be stiff initially; cycling them loosens the seal and spreads lubricant from the factory assembly.